Holiday Hours: Closed 12/24 - 12/26, and Closed 12/31 - 1/1

Local Favorites

This is our collection of some of our hyper-local favorites. From the Panhandle to St. Pete to Thomasville and beyond, we've locally curated the best of the best (including our RedEye Specialty items).

The perfect chance to keep it local and make it yours, we are proud to support these Florida & Georgia businesses, especially those within the 850. #iHeartTally

For "In Store Pick-Ups", we will contact you when your order is ready for contactless pick-up. If it is time-sensitive, please indicate that under "Special Instructions" upon checking out.

Filter by
Availability
Availability
45 results
Price
Price
45 results
$
$
Sort by Featured
Sort by

45 products

Triple Sweet Set available at Red Eye Coffee in Tallahassee, FL
Quick buy
$27.50
Red Eye Coffee Toffee available at Red Eye Coffee in Tallahassee, FL
Quick buy
From $15.50
Taste of Tally gift set in Tallahassee, FL.
Quick buy
$25.00
Quick buy
$26.00
Pumpkin Spice Cocoa Coffee Bag
Quick buy
$11.25
Cuddle Bundle located at RedEye Coffee in Tallahassee, FL
Quick buy
From $17.50
Mexican Hot Chocolate located at RedEye Coffee in Tallahassee, FL
Quick buy
$11.25
House Cocoa located at RedEye Coffee in Tallahassee, FL
Quick buy
$10.50
Peppermint cocoa from RedEye Coffee.
Quick buy
$11.25
RedEye Coffee Stickers located at RedEye Coffee in Tallahassee, FL
Quick buy
From $1.50
Ultimate Gift Set for Him with local food, coffee, and gifts from RedEye Coffee in Tallahassee, FL.
Quick buy
From $70.00
Quick buy
From $10.50
Cold brew concentrate from RedEye Coffee in Tallahassee, FL.
Quick buy
$28.00
Specialty To Go Jugs from RedEye Coffee in Tallahassee, FL.
Quick buy
From $13.00
Quick buy
From $16.00
The ultimate gift set for her with local food, coffee, and gifts from RedEye Coffee in Tallahassee, FL.
Quick buy
From $65.00
Harvested tupelo honey from Orchard Pond Organics in Tallahassee, FL.
Quick buy
$15.75
Wildflower honey from Orchard Pond Organics in Tallahassee, FL.
Quick buy
$8.00
Red Eye Logo
Quick buy
$10.00
Quick buy
$11.00

Looking for Catering?

We've got you! Browse our catering options for your next meeting or get-together.

Order Catering